Category Archives: Commentary

Tanks Again!?

Tank in Randolph 4th of July Parade

Forward Ho! A howitzer rolls down Main Street during the 4th of July parade in Randolph, Vermont in 1989.

Happy Fourth of July!

With the controversy swirling around President Trump’s decision to include tanks and other military hardware as part of a “Salute To America” celebration in Washington, D.C., we were reminded of a similar controversy 30 years ago in Randolph, Vt.

For many years, the annual Fourth of July parade in Randolph included a tank as part of the festivities. (We documented the militarization of the small town parade experience in Issues 5, 6 and 10.) This was around the time of the Tienanmen Square Massacre and the inclusion of the tank (we later learned it was actually a howitzer) rubbed some in town the wrong way.

In addition to protests published in the pages of The Advocate, one of the editors also threw daisies on the tank one year. Looking back, the argument made against inclusion of the tank was not very sophisticated, compelling or even cogent. But we received letters for and against our “anti-tank” stance with some questioning our patriotism.

Spirit of 1776

Proof of Patriotism: One of the editors of The Advocate dressed up as George Washington in kindergarten.\

As it was summed up 30 years ago in the pages of The Advocate, “There are better and more positive ways to make people think about the war for independence was fought for than this parading of military power.”

If you’re looking for a more appropriate way to celebrate Independence Day, listen to the annual tradition of NPR hosts reading the Declaration of Independence:

Commentary: Creation Myth (Volume 1, Issue 2)

What follows is commentary about Volume 1, Issue 2 by the founders and editors. of The Advocate. To the best of our recollection, this issue was published sometime in January 1989. The full issue is visible below or by clicking here. Please note that these pages are Genius-enabled, meaning that visitors can add context, links or corrections to any of the copy simply by selecting and right-clicking it.

Page 1

Scott Berkey – As I check out the first page of Issue 2, I am struck by how little I remember about how Issue 1 was received. How did we distribute it and where? How the hell did we sell ads for the first Issue? It has got to be a small town thing. You have these relationships that you can depend on (exploit).

Brendan Kinney – This is the issue when The Advocate got officially banned from school grounds. We took aim at Duffy Miller, the principal, and it was an extension of our behavior in the classroom as well. Scott was a well-known pain in the ass by many of his teachers (primarily due to his high IQ).

SB – I am not contesting this, but I can’t say that I ever perceived this myself. I knew I had various run ins with a lot of different teachers and administrators but somehow in my mind my level of ass-ness fell within what I perceived as the norm for a high school student.

BK – This might also be a myth of my own creation.

Continue reading

Celebrating 30 Years of Free Speech & Open Minds

Photo Credit: Bob Eddy

Photo Credit: Bob Eddy

Sometimes you aren’t sure what you are doing, but you still feel compelled to do it.

That was the case when we launched The Advocate thirty years ago. And it’s the case again today as we foist The Advocate Online upon you!

Driven by Gen-X nostalgia and the arrival of middle age, we present all 10 issues of The Advocate, which was an alternative newspaper published in Randolph, Vermont, USA from 1988-1990. Continue reading

Commentary: Opening the Time Capsule (Issue 1, Part I)

What follows is commentary about Volume 1, Issue 1 by the founders and editors. of The Advocate. The full issue is visible at the bottom of this page or by clicking The Advocate, Volume 1, Issue 1.

Page 1

Scott Berkey – Okay, here goes. I am going to crack open Volume 1, Issue 1 and see what drops out.  I don’t know for sure how long it has been since I have read this issue, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it is ten years and it could be closer to twenty. Once we stopped publishing I bagged and boxed up back issues and never really had time to go back to them. I thought about trying to pull together tenth, twentieth, and then twenty-fifth anniversary specials, but obviously that never went any further than keeping at least one copy of issue back issue safe and get the scans made.

Brendan Kinney – Quick quiz: What were you doing in November 1988?

Jamie Hill – I don’t have memories of how The Advocate came to be. I do remember walking around and selling ads. And indeed I’m shocked at how many of them we managed to sell! Do you guys remember how we brokered the favorable printing deal with the Herald? I was working at their press at the time … was Ben, too? (“Ben” was Brendan’s nickname in high school. It’s complicated. – Ed.) If not, then probably that would have been me who brokered that connection. I remember Dickey (Drysdale, former editor of The Herald of Randolph. – Ed.) gave us an incredibly sweet deal. Continue reading

Commentary: Opening The Time Capsule (Part II)

Page 2

Scott Berkey – It strikes me as I get to the second page that for all the long talks that Brendan and I had about the need for a new way for kids to speak to the world and for all the long talks we had about politics once we were really publishing something we didn’t really have much to go with.

Alexi somehow managed to finagle a credit in the masthead. Not sure how that happened or what he ever contributed. That really irked me at the time, but now it strikes me as just another piece of the mixed up puzzle that was The Advocate.

Brendan Kinney – I think he wrote one article, but we should corroborate.

SB – “Protests in the 1990s” is the first piece to appear in The Advocate with a legitimate byline.

BK – And there I go again, ranting about foreign policy, war and peace, and whatever else you got. It was around this time that I went to my first protest in Washington, D.C., although it was probably a year later during my first year in college. Ironically, Scott got off a bus just as I walked by with the Saint Mike’s contingent. He threw a rod on his Toyota Corolla flooring it to the bus stop where other Vermonters had gathered for the trip down.

SB – Brendan wasn’t the only one predicting (hoping) the 90’s would be like the sixties, but the momentum that seemed to be building almost came to a boil during Operation Desert Storm and then fizzled away. Continue reading